A legal intern is reading a case mat includes a majority opinion and a dissenting opinion rather than a unanimous decision The intern asks her mentor to explain the difference in precedential effect among the three.
Which of the following states the correct legal position?
选项:
A:
Only a unanimous decision creates binding legal precedent, but a majority opinion and a dissenting opinion can create persuasive authority
B:
Both unanimous decisions and majortty opinions create blndJng legal preceoent. but a dissenting opinion can create persuasive authority
C:
A unanimous decision creates binding legal precedent, a majority opinion may create only persuasive authority, and a dissenting opinion creates neither binding nor persuasive authority
D:
Unanimous decisions, majority opinions, and dissenting opinions all create binding precedent
Both unanimous decisions and majority opinions may create binding precedent, but persuasive authority can arise only from a dissenting opinion